The letters CC over snowy mountains
The Cache Citizen
Serving Cache County, UtahVol. 1, No. 22
Home & Family PLUS

Book Briefing: 'Boundaries' and the difference between a boulder and a knapsack

ShareFacebookXEmail
The front cover of the book Boundaries by Henry Cloud and John Townsend.
Cover image: Zondervan/HarperCollins Christian Publishing

By Home & Family PLUS Desk

Thanksgiving week is full of yeses. Yes, we'll host. Yes, we'll make the long drive. Yes, we'll sit next to the relative who wants to reopen last year's argument.

Some of those yeses come from love. Some come from guilt or fear. And if you've ever said yes with a smile and then stewed about it all the way home, this book is for you.

Boundaries: When to Say Yes, When to Say No to Take Control of Your Life came out in 1992, and it's still one of the most helpful books we know on telling those two kinds of yes apart.

Who wrote it

Henry Cloud and John Townsend are both clinical psychologists. Cloud earned his Ph.D. at Biola University, according to his own site (link). Townsend earned his at Biola's Rosemead School of Psychology and also has a master's in theology from Dallas Seminary, according to Concordia University Irvine (link).

So the book draws on two things: years of counseling people, and the authors' reading of the Bible.

Where you end and someone else begins

The big picture is a property line. A boundary, the authors write, "shows me where I end and someone else begins" (link).

Inside your fence are your feelings, your choices, your time and your attitudes. Those are yours to care for. What's inside someone else's fence isn't.

Boulders and knapsacks

This is the idea most readers remember. Galatians 6 seems to say two opposite things. In the New International Version, which the authors quote, verse 2 says to "carry each other's burdens," and verse 5 says "each one should carry their own load."

The authors explain it with a picture. A burden is a boulder. A load is a knapsack.

We should help each other with boulders, the crises and tragedies no one can lift alone. But each of us carries our own daily knapsack.

Trouble starts when we mix them up. Some people treat their boulders like knapsacks and won't let anyone help. Others treat their knapsacks like boulders and expect someone else to carry them.

Boundaries are about love

Today "boundaries" usually means protecting yourself. The American Psychological Association's dictionary calls a boundary "a psychological demarcation that protects the integrity of an individual or group" (link).

The book agrees, then goes further. The goal isn't just protection. It's love. As the authors put it in a later book, "setting limits helps us better own our lives and, ultimately, helps us love God and others better" (link).

Townsend writes that some people avoid boundaries because they think they're selfish, while "other people actually use boundaries to be selfish. Both are wrong" (link).

And here's the part that changes everything: a boundary isn't something you set on another person. It's about what you will do.

Don't turn it into a weapon

A boundary can be misused. Someone with a grudge can call it a "boundary" and cut people off over small hurts.

The Boundaries site draws a helpful line between hurting someone and harming them (link). Honest words may make someone uncomfortable. Unkind words injure.

Jesus called his followers to forgive and to love even their enemies. A boundary that serves love fits that. A boundary used as punishment doesn't.

The book's ideas come from counseling experience and Scripture. We didn't find a controlled study of its approach when we searched the authors' names in PubMed (link), so take it as wise counsel from experienced clinicians.

Why it gets five stars

Jeffrey Wallace, editor of The Cache Citizen, gives Boundaries five stars, his highest rating, on his list of recommended nonfiction. In his words, a life without clear boundaries is "a life without personal control." And for people with "controlling, manipulative, or irresponsible relationships, work conflicts, and emotional issues, this book is for you!"

The paperback is $13.99 on the publisher's site (link), but check your local library or ask a Cache Valley bookstore first.

What you can try this week

  • Decide before the day, not at the table. If you're leaving by 7 p.m., or skipping a gathering this year, say so early and kindly.
  • Set the limit on yourself, not on them. "You can't talk to me that way" can't be enforced. "If that comes up again, I'll step out for a walk" can.
  • Carry your own knapsack. Bring the dish you promised, help with the dishes and own your mood.
  • Help with a boulder. If your host is carrying something heavy this year, offer to take a real job off their plate.
  • Expect some hurt, but cause no harm. A disappointed relative isn't an injured one.
  • Keep a three-sentence script ready: "I love you, and I'm not going to talk about this today." "If it comes up again, I'm going to step outside for a few minutes." "I'd love to hear how your year has gone."
  • Ask one question before each yes: Is this a boulder someone needs help carrying, or a knapsack that belongs to them?

The point isn't to win Thanksgiving. It's to love people better, and to come home without the resentment.

This is a book review, not counseling or professional advice; if you're ever in an unsafe situation, call 911 or the National Domestic Violence Hotline (link) at 1-800-799-7233.

Drafted by AI from the linked public source. Approved by The Cache Citizen Editor, Jeffrey Wallace.

Sources and documents