Marriage & Parenting: Raising grateful kids in a 'gimme' season
By Home & Family PLUS Desk
You know the moment. Thanksgiving is Thursday, the Christmas lists are already coming in, and some of them are long. You read them, and a quiet worry gets louder: We gave them so much. Why do they expect more?
If you've felt that, you're not a bad parent. You're paying attention. And here's the hopeful part. Kids learn entitlement the same way they learn everything else: from what we teach them, on purpose or not. That means they can learn something better from us, too.
Praise the effort, not the ranking
For years we've been told that kids need to feel special before they can do well. The intent was good. Nobody wants a child to feel worthless.
But it hasn't held up the way we hoped. Psychologists who reviewed the research found that high self-esteem looks more like a result of doing well than a cause of it (link), and they warned that "indiscriminate praise might just as easily promote narcissism."
So try praising what your child did, not where they rank. "You stuck with that" builds something real. "You're the best" teaches them to expect the world to agree.
Warmth, yes. "Better than everyone," no.
This one is worth sitting with. Researchers in the Netherlands who followed a group of children over time found that kids whose parents saw them as better than others tended toward narcissism, while kids who got warmth tended toward healthy self-esteem (link).
So hug them. Enjoy them. Tell them you love them. Warmth builds confidence. Telling a child he's better than other people builds something else.
The ads are talking to your kids
Here's something to keep in mind this week. Most kids under 7 or 8 don't recognize the sales pitch in an ad (link). They believe what they're told, and the people doing the telling are paid to make them want things.
No study we know of proves that ads make kids entitled. That part is our own hunch. But it's worth thinking about what a steady stream of "you need this" does to a young heart, especially with Black Friday on Nov. 27.
Thankful to Someone
Gratitude isn't just a trick for feeling better. It's the right response to a Giver.
Remember the ten lepers? Jesus healed all ten, and only one came back to give thanks. "Were there not ten cleansed? but where are the nine?" (Luke 17:17). He noticed.
Then there's the prodigal son. We usually think about the son who ran off, but the entitled one is the son who stayed home. "Lo, these many years do I serve thee," the older brother says, "and yet thou never gavest me a kid" (Luke 15:29).
His father doesn't hand him more. He says: "Son, thou art ever with me, and all that I have is thine" (Luke 15:31).
That's the cure, isn't it? Not more stuff. Seeing how much has already been given.
And Paul preserved Jesus' words that "It is more blessed to give than to receive" (Acts 20:35). Our kids can learn that one best by doing it.
Thanks before the box opens
A lot of entitlement comes down to order. The gift comes before the gratitude. The toy comes before the work.
So flip it. Let a wish wait a while, or let them work toward it. Give fewer, better gifts. And put thanks before the box opens.
Our kids are going to learn entitlement from somebody. With a little intention, they can learn gratitude from us instead.
A simple plan for Thanksgiving week
- Sunday: Read Luke 17:11-19, the ten lepers, together. Ask: "Why do you think only one came back?"
- Monday: Catch each child doing something good and name the effort ("You stuck with that"), not a ranking ("You're the best").
- Tuesday: Watch or scroll for 15 minutes while the kids tally the ads. Ask who paid for each one.
- Wednesday: Before anyone finishes a Christmas list, each person writes three thank-you notes for things received this year.
- Thursday (Thanksgiving): At the table, ask: "Name one thing someone did for you this year that they didn't have to do."
- Friday (Black Friday): A new want goes on a dated list to revisit later, or your child saves toward it.
- Saturday: Let each child choose a gift for someone who can't repay it, and deliver it together.
Three questions to ask about each Christmas gift
Will it build something in this child? Did they wait or work for any part of it? Will they say thank you before they open it?
This is one parent's encouragement, not professional advice. If you're worried about your child or your marriage, talk with your pediatrician, a counselor or your pastor.