san jose collage
San Jose
Serving San Jose, California (Santa Clara County)Vol. 1, No. 23
Government

Trump waives most Clean Water Act rules for aerial fire retardant through Nov. 10, 2027, after a court found illegal drops in California

The waiver, published in the Federal Register on Monday, covers federal firefighting from Nov. 10, 2026, through Nov. 10, 2027.  A Montana judge found unpermitted drops in California and nine other states violated the law.

ShareFacebookXEmail
Workers at a metal table measure red fire retardant under a shade canopy at an airfield, with tanks, blue pumps and an air tanker in the background
Red fire retardant is measured at the U.S. Forest Service’s Fresno Air Attack Base on Aug. 30, 2025, during the Garnet Fire in Sierra National Forest.  An air tanker sits on the ramp in the background. — Photo:  U.S. Forest Service photo by Sam Wu

President Donald Trump has exempted federal firefighting, including the aerial use of fire retardant, from most Clean Water Act water-pollution rules for one year, according to a presidential determination published Monday in the Federal Register.

The waiver, signed Nov. 10 as Presidential Determination No. 2027-03, runs through Nov. 10, 2027.  It covers the U.S. Forest Service, the Interior Department, other federal agencies and their contractors.  It lifts federal, state, interstate and local water-pollution requirements, procedures and penalties, except two Clean Water Act standards on new sources and toxic pollutants.

Trump invoked a Clean Water Act provision that lets the president grant a one-year exemption if he finds it is in the “paramount interest of the United States.”  A White House fact sheet said a federal court decision requires a Clean Water Act permit for aerial retardant, and that the Forest Service has not obtained one.

In a May 26, 2023, order, U.S. District Judge Dana L. Christensen in Montana found that the Forest Service’s unpermitted aerial retardant discharges into navigable waters in California and nine other states violated the Clean Water Act.  He did not ban the drops.  In a May 19, 2025, order, he again required the Forest Service to obtain a federal discharge permit, known as an NPDES permit, and again refused to halt retardant use while the permit was pending.  That 2025 order said the Environmental Protection Agency had withdrawn a draft permit after the change in presidential administrations and later sent it back to the White House budget office for review.

The memorandum says it is not meant to decide whether a permit would be required without the waiver, and that other laws still apply.

What it means

Planes will keep dropping retardant on wildfires either way: the judge refused twice to stop the drops, writing in 2023 that a ban could mean more wildfire harm to people, property and the environment. What changes for the next year is the paperwork and the penalties. The Forest Service and other federal fire crews won't need a water-pollution permit for drops that land in streams and lakes, and California and local agencies can't use their own water rules to punish those drops.

The trade-off is water quality. Retardant is mostly fertilizer-type salts, the 2023 order says, and the Forest Service told the court that retardant reaching a stream can, in some cases, kill fish and other water life or harm their habitat, though it said deadly cases are expected to be extremely rare. The group that sued, Forest Service Employees for Environmental Ethics, counted at least 459 drops into waterways from 2012 to 2019, totaling about 761,000 gallons. One member said drops harmed Sespe Creek near his home in Ojai, in Southern California. The Forest Service said its 213 recorded drops into water were accidents (190) or were needed to protect lives or public safety (23).

Source:  Presidential Determination No. 2027-03, 91 Fed. Reg. 73645 (Nov. 16, 2026); White House memorandum, Nov. 10, 2026; U.S. District Court for the District of Montana, orders of May 26, 2023, and May 19, 2025.

Drafted by AI from the linked public source. Approved by a Daily News Editor.

Sources and documents