san jose collage
San Jose
Serving San Jose, California (Santa Clara County)Vol. 1, No. 23
Astronomy

The ice around a nearby young star is probably older than the star itself, Webb finds

Glassy water ice laced with dry ice around Beta Pictoris, 63 light-years away, likely froze in interstellar cold before the star was born.  It hints that the makings of water worlds come ready-made.

ShareFacebookXEmail
A thin, wide horizontal orange band of dust seen edge-on across a black background, with a fainter blue-green band tilted slightly against it, a black circle and bar at center blocking the star, and a curved gray wisp at upper right.
Webb's 2024 mid-infrared image of the Beta Pictoris debris disk, seen edge-on.  Orange is light at 23 microns and blue-green is 15.5 microns; the black disk and bar block the star's glare.  It shows the disk's dust, not the new ice measurements. — NASA, ESA, CSA, STScI, C. Stark and K. Lawson (NASA GSFC), J. Kammerer (ESO), and M. Perrin (STScI); CC BY 4.0; padded to 3:2, not cropped

Ice in the dusty disk around Beta Pictoris, a young star 63 light-years away, most likely formed in the cold space between stars before the star itself was born, according to a study published Nov. 12 in the journal Science.  The James Webb Space Telescope found frozen water and frozen carbon dioxide in the disk, and the way the water ice is built points to a birthplace in deep interstellar cold.

What they found

Beta Pictoris is about 370 trillion miles away; the light reaching us now left it around 1963.  It is a young star, roughly 20 million years old, compared with the Sun's 4.6 billion.  It is ringed by a debris disk, a flat, dusty band of rock and ice made as asteroids, comets and young planets smash into one another.  It was the first such disk ever photographed around another star, and planets are still forming in it.

Webb's spectrograph split the disk's reflected light into its colors.  Ice absorbs certain infrared colors, leaving dark fingerprints.  The team found both water ice and carbon dioxide ice, the stuff of dry ice, including a rarer form of carbon dioxide made with a heavier type of carbon.  The two are mixed in the same grains, about one carbon dioxide molecule for every 10 water molecules.  The icy dust is spread evenly across the disk, which the team says means icy bodies in it are colliding often and keep releasing fresh ice.

Why the ice is probably older than the star

The key clue is the ice's structure.  Water that freezes slowly and gently lines up into crystals, like the ice in a freezer.  Water that freezes extremely fast and extremely cold, as on dust in space, locks into a jumbled, glass-like form called amorphous ice.  Less than 7% of the water ice around Beta Pictoris is crystalline.  Amorphous ice generally survives only below about minus 280 degrees Fahrenheit, about 100 degrees above absolute zero.  The authors say that, together with the carbon dioxide mixed into it, this implies the ice formed in very cold conditions, likely in the interstellar cloud the star was born from.  That is an inference from the ice's makeup, not a direct measure of its age.  The result has passed peer review but has not been independently repeated.

What it means

The ice that comets carry in our own solar system is also thought to be partly inherited from the cloud the Sun formed in, and comets are one suspected source of some of Earth's water.  Finding the same kind of glassy, carbon dioxide-laced ice around another young star suggests the raw ingredients for water-rich planets may come pre-made and be common, not a quirk of our neighborhood.

Can you see it from San Jose?

Not really.  Beta Pictoris is a faint naked-eye star deep in the southern sky.  From San Jose it never climbs more than about 2 degrees above the southern horizon, roughly the width of a finger at arm's length, so haze and hills hide it.  It is easy to see from the Southern Hemisphere.

The telescope

Webb, a joint NASA, European Space Agency and Canadian Space Agency observatory, launched on Dec. 25, 2021, and works about 1 million miles from Earth, where its 21-foot gold-coated mirror stays cold enough to see faint infrared light.  It cost roughly $10 billion.  The study used its Near Infrared Spectrograph, or NIRSpec, which the European Space Agency supplied.  The team has posted its processed Webb data publicly.

Source:  S. K. Betti et al., Carbon dioxide and amorphous water ices in the debris disk around β Pictoris, Science, Vol. 394, published Nov. 12, 2026 (abstract and editor's summary; full paper paywalled); the team's public data set on Dryad; ESA/Webb, Webb discovers dusty cat's tail in Beta Pictoris system, Jan. 10, 2024, for the distance and disk background.  Mile, light-time and horizon figures are the Daily News's own arithmetic.  Drafted by AI for San Jose.

Drafted by AI from the linked public source. Approved by a Daily News Editor.

Sources and documents