From the archives, Nov. 17, 1917: The Monitor hails segregation law ruling
Omaha's Black weekly called the Supreme Court's Louisville decision the greatest legal victory in years.
Omaha Commons revisits The Monitor of Nov. 17, 1917, when Omaha's Black weekly reported a U.S. Supreme Court ruling against a city housing segregation law.
OMAHA — The U.S. Supreme Court had struck down Louisville's residential segregation ordinance as a violation of the Constitution, The Monitor reported on its front page Nov. 17, 1917. The paper said the court ruled on a Monday earlier that month.
The Louisville law, in effect since May 11, 1914, called for separate blocks for white and Black residents. The Monitor said the decision also left similar ordinances in Baltimore, St. Louis, Richmond and other cities without force.
Justice Day wrote the opinion, and the paper reported that every justice concurred. It quoted his finding that the state's police power, broad as it is, cannot justify a law that "runs counter to the limitations of the federal constitution."
Black residents of Louisville who fought the measure argued that it barred them from healthy neighborhoods and confined them to crowded ones. Moorfield Storey, the Boston lawyer the paper identified as national president of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, made the principal arguments against the ordinances.
The Monitor, edited by the Rev. John Albert Williams, called the decision the greatest legal victory for Black Americans since the Supreme Court's ruling in the Grandfather Clause case some years before.
Source: The Monitor (Omaha, Neb.), Nov. 17, 1917, page 1, via Library of Congress, Chronicling America (LCCN 00225879). The Library of Congress says U.S. newspapers published more than 95 years ago are in the public domain.
How we checked this: Reported from The Monitor, Nov. 17, 1917, page 1, on the Library of Congress Chronicling America site, opened Nov. 17, 2026, at 5:20 a.m. CT, and checked against the record by our copy desk before publishing.