Cache County remains majority Latter-day Saint as its share falls and other faiths grow, records show
Membership counts, surveys, congregation pages and commentary describe what residents believe, who the county's religious minorities are, the debate over Joseph Smith and plural marriage, and where neighbors of different faiths meet.
LOGAN - About seven in 10 Cache County residents are Latter-day Saints, according to both a 2020 congregational count and a 2023 survey-based estimate, but the county's religious life is broader, and changing faster, than that one number suggests. The 2020 U.S. Religion Census county report (link) counted 97,751 adherents of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, 73% of the county's 133,154 residents, while the 2023 PRRI Census of American Religion (link) estimated that 70% of Cache County adults identify as Latter-day Saints.
Around that majority are Catholic parishioners worshipping in English and Spanish, nearly 20 other Christian congregations, a mosque that a member says has run out of room, a Buddhist-inspired meditation group, Unitarians, Baha'is, Jewish residents without a synagogue, and, statewide, about a third of adults who claim no religion at all, according to a 2023-24 Pew survey. This story draws on survey data, membership counts, official church and congregation pages, published research, other newsrooms' reporting and commentary, and labels each. Every figure names its source and year.
Two ways to count: membership and self-identification
The two headline numbers measure different things. The U.S. Religion Census, compiled by the Association of Statisticians of American Religious Bodies and published by the Association of Religion Data Archives, is a membership count: religious bodies report their own adherents, children included. PRRI's figure is survey data, a statistical estimate built from about 417,000 adult interviews nationwide from 2014 to 2023. PRRI says its county estimates carry larger error in smaller counties.
Statewide surveys find a lower share. In Pew Research Center's 2023-24 Religious Landscape Study (link) (survey data), 50% of Utah adults identified as Latter-day Saints, 63% as Christians of any kind, 34% as religiously unaffiliated and 2% with other religions, with a margin of error of plus or minus 7.3 points. The Church's Utah facts and statistics page (link) (membership count) lists 2,206,370 members in the state, viewed Nov. 13, 2026. The Utah Foundation (link) noted in October 2025 that membership rolls do not show how many members actually attend.
Roughly who belongs to what
The 2020 U.S. Religion Census (link) (membership count) lists these Cache County adherents. The percentages of the county's 2020 population are The Cache Citizen's calculations from the report's figures.
- Latter-day Saints: 97,751 (73.4%)
- Catholic Church: 8,000 (6.0%)
- Evangelical Protestant bodies, including nondenominational churches, Assemblies of God, Southern Baptists, Seventh-day Adventists, Church of God, Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod and Churches of Christ: 1,726 combined (1.3%)
- Jehovah's Witnesses: 670 (0.5%)
- Muslims, an estimate the census marks as such: 631 (0.5%)
- Mainline Protestant bodies, including Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), Episcopal, Evangelical Lutheran Church in America and Quaker: 546 combined (0.4%)
- Unitarian Universalists: 45; Baha'i Faith: 32
- A Hindu yoga and meditation group and an Evangelical Free Church congregation are listed with no adherent count
- Not counted as adherents of any reporting group: about 17.8%
That last group is not the same as "nonreligious." It can include people who belong to no congregation, members of bodies that did not report, and people whose faith has no local congregation. No Jewish congregation appears in the county report. The census itself warns that collection methods change from one count to the next.
What people believe, and how religious they are
Belief runs wider than belonging. Pew's 2025 overview of the 2023-24 study (link) (survey data) found that 83% of U.S. adults believe in God or a universal spirit, 86% believe people have a soul or spirit, and 70% believe in an afterlife. Pew's Utah page includes belief charts, but The Cache Citizen could not retrieve Utah-specific belief figures in a form it could verify for this story, so the national figures are used here.
Religious practice in Utah remains high by national standards. The Utah Foundation reported in October 2025 (link) (survey data) that 41% of Utahns said in 2024 they attend services at least weekly, ranking the state second only to Mississippi. The foundation's 2021 community-life report (link) found that nearly two-thirds of Utah volunteering in 2018 happened through a religious organization.
The nonreligious
In Pew's 2023-24 Utah figures (survey data), the 34% who claim no religion break down into 4% atheist, 10% agnostic and 20% "nothing in particular." Nationally, Pew's 2024 report on religious "nones" (link) (survey data) found most of them believe in God or another higher power; just 29% reject any higher power or spiritual force. Asked about religion's role in society, 43% of nones said it does more harm than good, 14% said more good than harm, and 41% said it does about equal amounts of each.
Several local groups say plainly that people without a faith are welcome. Northern Utah Insight (link), a meditation community that meets in Logan, says its Buddhist-based practices are open to people of all religious, spiritual and secular backgrounds. Utah State University's Interfaith Initiative (link) describes its work as conversations about "religious (or lack of religious) commitments." Logan's Unitarian Universalist congregation, known as CVUU, says on its beliefs page (link) that it has "no shared creed." The Cache Citizen did not find an official website for a local secular or humanist organization, so none is described here.
Growing or declining?
Both, depending on the measure. In U.S. Religion Census counts (membership counts), Latter-day Saint adherents in Cache County rose from 73,571 in 2000 (link) to 92,665 in 2010 (link) and 97,751 in 2020. By The Cache Citizen's calculation from the census counts, the Latter-day Saint share rose from 80.5% of residents in 2000 to 82.3% in 2010, then fell to 73.4% in 2020 as the county grew faster, from 91,391 residents in 2000 to 133,154 in 2020. Over the same three counts, Catholic adherents grew from 1,953 to 3,308 to 8,000, and the census's Muslim estimate from 163 to 308 to 631. The census cautions that its methods changed between counts.
Statewide, the Latter-day Saint share of Utah adults fell from 58% in 2007 to 55% in 2014 and 50% in 2023-24 in Pew's surveys, the Deseret News reported (link) in February 2025. Weekly attendance fell from 57% of Utahns in 2007 to 41% in 2024, according to the Utah Foundation's 2025 report (survey data).
Nationally, the long slide may be leveling off. Pew found the Christian share of U.S. adults dropped from 78% in 2007 to 71% in 2014 and 62% in 2023-24, but has hovered between 60% and 64% since 2019 (survey data). PRRI's 2025 Census of American Religion (link), released April 15, 2026 (survey data), found 28% of Americans unaffiliated in 2025, similar to 2024. One group is still moving: the unaffiliated share of women ages 18 to 29 rose from 29% in 2013 to 43% in 2025, while young men stayed at 35%.
Institutions are still building. The Church's Smithfield Utah Temple page (link) and its temple open houses and dedications page (link) list April 18, 2027, as the temple's dedication date, which would give Cache County a second temple alongside the Logan Utah Temple, dedicated in 1884, according to the Church's Utah facts page.
Belonging to a religious minority
Published accounts from members of minority faiths describe welcome and isolation side by side. In a 2024 Utah Statesman article (link), Ronen Sebag, then USU's senior adviser for inclusive excellence, said:
"There is not a single public Jewish space in Cache Valley. ... It is challenging to be Jewish here." (Ronen Sebag, The Utah Statesman, April 2024)
Hillel for Utah (link), the statewide Jewish student program, says it serves students at USU among other campuses and is based in Salt Lake City.
At a 2023 USU interfaith iftar, the meal that breaks the Ramadan fast, Rana Abulbasal, who received a doctorate from USU's Department of Sociology and Anthropology in August 2023, according to the university's dissertation archive (link), told Utah Public Radio (link) the local Muslim community is small and "made up of students, because this is a college town," along with many refugees. In March 2026, Issa Hamud, a member of the Logan Islamic Center (link), told the Herald Journal (link) the community had grown "to the point that sometimes we have to pray outside in order to include everyone."
Christians outside the Latter-day Saint majority are minorities here too. USU Residence Life's list of local religious services (link) names 22 congregations and groups outside the Latter-day Saint faith, including Logan Chinese Baptist Church and Casa Del Alfarero, whose own site (link) advertises a bilingual Sunday service. St. Thomas Aquinas Parish (link) in Hyde Park lists Saturday and Sunday Masses in Spanish as well as English, and a Newman Center for students near campus.
Do USU students graduate with more or less belief in God?
The Cache Citizen found no published study that measures how USU students' belief in God changes between enrollment and graduation. The best published research is national and is not USU-specific. A 2007 study in Social Forces by Jeremy Uecker, Mark Regnerus and Margaret Vaaler, "Losing My Religion" (link), using national Add Health survey data, found that young adults who skip college show the most religious decline, and that religious participation, not religion's importance, is what drops most in early adulthood.
A 2011 follow-up in Social Forces (link) by Damon Mayrl and Uecker, using the National Survey of Youth and Religion, found college students were no more likely than nonstudents to develop more liberal religious beliefs and sometimes more likely to keep their original beliefs. The authors linked belief change more strongly to friends and social networks. Whether those patterns hold on a campus where most students share one faith is a question the published research does not answer.
New and contested ideas: Joseph Smith and plural marriage
A debate over whether Joseph Smith, the faith's founder, practiced plural marriage has drawn a growing audience among some Latter-day Saints. The Salt Lake Tribune reported in March 2026 (link) that the Church's release of the Joseph Smith Papers, beginning in the early 2000s, led many members and historians to study the question further. The Church announced the final volume of the 27-volume project (link) on June 27, 2023.
The Church's own publications take a clear position. Its Gospel Topics essay "Plural Marriage in Kirtland and Nauvoo" (link) says that after receiving a revelation, "Joseph Smith married multiple wives and introduced the practice to close associates," and a footnote puts careful estimates at 30 to 40 wives. The Church's newsroom (link) says the practice began in Joseph Smith's lifetime and is prohibited today. The Joseph Smith Papers' introduction to the July 12, 1843 revelation (link), now Doctrine and Covenants 132, says that from early 1843 he was sealed to "at least thirteen additional wives, most of whom were married to him without Emma's knowledge."
Advocates of the opposite view argue that Joseph Smith told the truth when he publicly denied practicing polygamy, and that later leaders shaped the record. Critics often call the view "polygamy denial," a label the Tribune reported is meant to echo "Holocaust denier." Three YouTube channels cited here make that case. All three are commentary.
- Michelle Stone's 132 Problems: Revisiting Mormon Polygamy (link). In "161: Brigham’s Transfiguration & Joseph’s Polygamy: Two Dubious Narratives" (March 16, 2025) (link), its description argues that the story of Joseph Smith's polygamy "suffers from the exact same problems" as a disputed account about Brigham Young. In "The Return of 132 Problems" (June 12, 2026) (link), Stone says she is bringing the channel back as she moves for school.
- Jeremy Hoop's StillMormon (link). Its Ep28 (Sept. 27, 2026) (link) asks why people reach different conclusions from the same documents and presents what its description calls a "NEW MODEL" for reading them. Ep33 (Nov. 3, 2026) (link) questions the evidence that Joseph Smith had sexual relations with plural wives.
- Karen Hyatt's Joseph Told The Truth (link). Her documentary "Woe Unto You, Scribes: The Hidden History of Polygamy" (Oct. 11, 2024) (link) lists chapters on Joseph and Hyrum Smith preaching against polygamy, on teachings "revised" after Joseph's death, and on the provenance of Section 132. In a Dec. 7, 2025 video (link), Hyatt said a church membership council had withdrawn her membership, that she would appeal, and that she still planned to attend church.
Stone told the Tribune in March 2026, "I am a faithful and lifelong member," adding, "I have never wanted to be viewed as an enemy." She discounts many women's accounts of marrying Smith as too far removed from his lifetime; the Tribune reported that many of those affidavits and testimonies were not produced until "30 to 40 years after Smith was killed." She told the Tribune, "We should not think that the verdict is in on all of these stories." She co-founded the Journal of Mormon Polygamy with Cheryl Bruno, who, the Tribune reported, believes Smith did take multiple wives.
Historians who disagree with Stone point to the women's own accounts. Brooke LeFevre, a Baylor University doctoral candidate who studies 19th-century Latter-day Saint women, told the Tribune: "To deny Joseph Smith practiced polygamy is to ignore the voices of so many women." Historian Matthew Bowman, Howard W. Hunter Chair of Mormon Studies at Claremont Graduate University, argued in a September 2025 Tribune commentary (link) that the movement fits a "declension narrative" and a wider suspicion of institutions. FAIR, a volunteer group that defends the faith, argued in a July 2025 post (link) (commentary) that William Clayton's Nauvoo journals are not "revised history." The Tribune reported in July 2026 (link) that the Church's annotated edition of Clayton's diaries is due in 2027 from Yale University Press, giving readers another primary source to weigh.
Hoop and Hyatt are both scheduled to speak at MormonX, an independent conference Nov. 20-21 at American Fork Junior High School. According to the conference's presenter page (link), Hoop's talk asks "what the title prophet actually implies" and "what that might change about how we understand Joseph Smith," and Hyatt's offers tips for discussing polygamy and other "touchy topics" with friends and family. Passes are $85, according to the registration page (link).
Other currents
- Christianity is diversifying locally. Nondenominational Christian adherents in the county rose from 419 in 2010 to 630 in 2020, according to the U.S. Religion Census, and St. Thomas Aquinas Parish and Casa Del Alfarero list Spanish or bilingual services.
- Contemplative practice is crossing lines. Northern Utah Insight meets weekly in Logan for meditation open to people of any background.
- Young adults, especially young women, are the group most likely to leave organized religion nationally, according to PRRI's 2025 data.
- The Muslim community's growth has outpaced its building, a member told the Herald Journal in 2026.
How people with differing beliefs are meeting
County residents have regular, official chances to meet across lines. The 2026 Tour of Faiths schedule (link) lists 10 faith communities opening their doors over two weekends, the first on Nov. 13-14 and the second on Nov. 20-21, from Catholic, Lutheran, Episcopal, Adventist and Presbyterian churches to a Latter-day Saint meetinghouse, the Logan Islamic Center, CVUU and Northern Utah Insight. On Nov. 21, the Islamic Center asks visitors to dress modestly and remove shoes at the entrance.
The tour's host guidelines (link) ask each community to focus on "mutual understanding and education rather than conversion or proselytizing," and ask visitors to hold their own views unless invited to share. Cache Community Connections (link), the interfaith council behind the tour, says it exists to "build understanding, facilitate respect, and establish partnerships." Its annual Gratitude Concert, with musicians from several faith communities, is set for Sunday, Nov. 22, at 7 p.m. at St. Thomas Aquinas Catholic Church in Hyde Park.
On campus, USU's Interfaith Initiative (link) offers an Interfaith Leadership Certificate and reflection rooms where students and faculty can pray or meditate. Bonnie Glass-Coffin, listed in USU's faculty directory (link) as an emeritus professor in the School of Social Sciences, told Utah Public Radio in 2023 that interfaith gatherings "help to build relationships of trust and appreciation."
The data point to common ground as well. Most Americans, including most of the nonreligious, tell Pew they believe in something beyond the physical world, and Utah's high volunteer rate runs largely through congregations, the Utah Foundation found. Neighbors who disagree about doctrine often already serve side by side.
Why this matters
Cache County is often described in one word. The record shows a Latter-day Saint majority that is still large but shrinking as a share, a sizable share of people with no religion, and minority communities that describe feeling small or unseen. Knowing who your neighbors are, and how differently careful sources count them, makes it easier to find your own place in the county and to meet others where they are.
Source: U.S. Religion Census 2020, Cache County membership report (ASARB via ARDA) (link), with every source listed below.
Sources
- U.S. Religion Census 2020, Cache County membership report (ASARB via ARDA) (link): membership count, 2020 data.
- U.S. Religion Census 2010, Cache County report (link): membership count, 2010 data.
- U.S. Religion Census 2000, Cache County report (link): membership count, 2000 data.
- PRRI, 2023 Census of American Religion: County-Level Data (link): survey data, Aug. 29, 2024.
- PRRI, 2025 Census of American Religion (link): survey data, April 15, 2026.
- Pew Research Center, Religious Landscape Study: People in Utah (2023-24) (link): survey data, 2025.
- Pew Research Center, Decline of Christianity in the U.S. Has Slowed, May Have Leveled Off (link): survey data, Feb. 26, 2025.
- Pew Research Center, Religious 'Nones' in America (link): survey data, Jan. 24, 2024.
- Utah Foundation, Neighborhoods and Networks (Social Capital series) (link): survey data / analysis, Oct. 2025.
- Utah Foundation, The Art of Association (link): survey data / analysis, Dec. 2021.
- Church of Jesus Christ newsroom, Utah facts and statistics (link): membership count / official page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- Church of Jesus Christ, Smithfield Utah Temple page (link): official page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- Church of Jesus Christ, Temple Open Houses and Dedications (link): official page, viewed Nov. 14, 2026.
- Church of Jesus Christ, Gospel Topics essay: Plural Marriage in Kirtland and Nauvoo (link): official church publication, undated essay, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- Church of Jesus Christ newsroom, Polygamy: Latter-day Saints and the Practice of Plural Marriage (link): official church publication, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- Church newsroom, Final Volume of Joseph Smith Papers Published (link): official church publication, June 27, 2023.
- [Joseph Smith Papers, Revelation, 12 July 1843 [D&C 132], historical introduction (link)](https://www.josephsmithpapers.org/paper-summary/revelation-12-july-1843-dc-132/1): official church publication / primary document, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- Uecker, Regnerus and Vaaler, Losing My Religion, Social Forces 85(4) (link): published research (national, not USU-specific), June 2007.
- Mayrl and Uecker, Higher Education and Religious Liberalization among Young Adults, Social Forces 90(1) (link): published research (national, not USU-specific), 2011.
- 2026 Tour of Faiths schedule (cvfaithtours.com) (link): official page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- Tour of Faiths host guidelines (link): official page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- Cache Community Connections (link): official page, Oct. 16, 2026 post.
- USU Interfaith Initiative (link): official page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- USU Interfaith Initiative, About (link): official page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- USU Residence Life, Local Religious Services (link): official page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- Casa Del Alfarero (link): official congregation page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- St. Thomas Aquinas Parish (link): official congregation page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- Logan Islamic Center (link): official congregation page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- CVUU, Our Beliefs (link): official congregation page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- Northern Utah Insight (link): official group page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- Hillel for Utah, About (link): official page, viewed Nov. 13, 2026.
- 132 Problems: Revisiting Mormon Polygamy (Michelle Stone), YouTube channel (link): commentary, YouTube channel.
- 132 Problems, 161: Brigham's Transfiguration & Joseph's Polygamy: Two Dubious Narratives (link): commentary, March 16, 2025.
- 132 Problems, The Return of 132 Problems (link): commentary, June 12, 2026.
- StillMormon (Jeremy Hoop), YouTube channel (link): commentary, YouTube channel.
- StillMormon, Ep28: Was Joseph Smith a RELUCTANT polygamist or a CONMAN? (link): commentary, Sept. 27, 2026.
- StillMormon, Ep33: Is there credible EVIDENCE that Joseph Smith had sex with any of the alleged wives? (link): commentary, Nov. 3, 2026.
- Joseph Told The Truth (Karen Hyatt), YouTube channel (link): commentary, YouTube channel.
- Joseph Told The Truth, Woe Unto You, Scribes: The Hidden History of Polygamy (link): commentary, Oct. 11, 2024.
- Joseph Told The Truth, Can A Mormon Defend Joseph Smith AND Stay in the Church...? (link): commentary, Dec. 7, 2025.
- FAIR, Are William Clayton's journals ... just 'revised history'? (link): commentary (apologetics), July 25, 2025.
- Salt Lake Tribune, Conference questions if LDS Church founder Joseph Smith was polygamous (Courtney Tanner) (link): other newsroom, attributed, March 21, 2026.
- Salt Lake Tribune, More evidence soon to be published of Joseph Smith's polygamy (Peggy Fletcher Stack) (link): other newsroom, attributed, July 18, 2026.
- Salt Lake Tribune commentary, Rewriting the Mormon past (Matthew Bowman) (link): commentary, Sept. 30, 2025.
- Deseret News, How many Utahns are Latter-day Saints? (Kelsey Dallas) (link): other newsroom, attributed, Feb. 28, 2025.
- The Utah Statesman, Jewish Inclusion Seminar gives diverse voices a platform (Lacey Cintron) (link): other newsroom, attributed, April 1, 2024.
- Utah Public Radio, USU Interfaith Initiative hosts Iftar (Anna Johnson) (link): other newsroom, attributed, April 20, 2023.
- Herald Journal, report on the Islamic community's search for more space (Keith Fike) (link): other newsroom, attributed, March 13, 2026.
- USU faculty directory, Bonnie Glass-Coffin (link): official page, viewed Nov. 14, 2026.
- USU DigitalCommons, Rana Abulbasal dissertation record (link): official page, degree awarded Aug. 2023.
- MormonX, Meet the Presenters (link): conference listing, accessed Nov. 15, 2026.
- MormonX, Register for MormonX 2026 (link): conference listing, accessed Nov. 15, 2026.
- U.S. Religion Census 2020, Cache County membership report (ASARB via ARDA)
- U.S. Religion Census 2010, Cache County report
- U.S. Religion Census 2000, Cache County report
- PRRI, 2023 Census of American Religion: County-Level Data
- PRRI, 2025 Census of American Religion
- Pew Research Center, Religious Landscape Study: People in Utah (2023-24)
- Pew Research Center, Decline of Christianity in the U.S. Has Slowed, May Have Leveled Off
- Pew Research Center, Religious 'Nones' in America
- Utah Foundation, Neighborhoods and Networks (Social Capital series)
- Utah Foundation, The Art of Association
- Church of Jesus Christ newsroom, Utah facts and statistics
- Church of Jesus Christ, Smithfield Utah Temple page
- Church of Jesus Christ, Gospel Topics essay: Plural Marriage in Kirtland and Nauvoo
- Church of Jesus Christ newsroom, Polygamy: Latter-day Saints and the Practice of Plural Marriage
- Church newsroom, Final Volume of Joseph Smith Papers Published
- Joseph Smith Papers, Revelation, 12 July 1843 [D&C 132], historical introduction
- Uecker, Regnerus and Vaaler, Losing My Religion, Social Forces 85(4)
- Mayrl and Uecker, Higher Education and Religious Liberalization among Young Adults, Social Forces 90(1)
- 2026 Tour of Faiths schedule (cvfaithtours.com)
- Tour of Faiths host guidelines
- Cache Community Connections
- USU Interfaith Initiative
- USU Interfaith Initiative, About
- USU Residence Life, Local Religious Services
- St. Thomas Aquinas Parish
- Logan Islamic Center
- CVUU, Our Beliefs
- Northern Utah Insight
- Hillel for Utah, About
- 132 Problems: Revisiting Mormon Polygamy (Michelle Stone), YouTube channel
- 132 Problems, 161: Brigham's Transfiguration & Joseph's Polygamy: Two Dubious Narratives
- 132 Problems, The Return of 132 Problems
- StillMormon (Jeremy Hoop), YouTube channel
- StillMormon, Ep28: Was Joseph Smith a RELUCTANT polygamist or a CONMAN?
- StillMormon, Ep33: Is there credible EVIDENCE that Joseph Smith had sex with any of the alleged wives?
- Joseph Told The Truth (Karen Hyatt), YouTube channel
- Joseph Told The Truth, Woe Unto You, Scribes: The Hidden History of Polygamy
- Joseph Told The Truth, Can A Mormon Defend Joseph Smith AND Stay in the Church...?
- Casa Del Alfarero (congregation site)
- Church of Jesus Christ, Temple Open Houses and Dedications
- USU faculty directory, Bonnie Glass-Coffin
- USU DigitalCommons, Rana Abulbasal dissertation record
- MormonX, Meet the Presenters
- MormonX, Register for MormonX 2026